By Christoph Lubczyk | Project Leader
Dorothea is an environmental consultant for
the alliance organization of Aktion Deutschland
Hilft, ADRA Germany. She has spent over a
decade working in rural development in
sub-Saharan Africa. Today, her work includes
exploring how humanitarian aid can be made more
environmentally friendly.
The "Do No Harm" principle is a cornerstone of
humanitarian aid: interventions should assist
people in crisis without causing any unintended
harm. In this interview, she discusses "Do No
Environmental Harm" an approach that specifically
focuses on preventing negative impacts on the
environment.
Aktion Deutschland Hilft: The term "Do No Harm" has
been well-established in the humanitarian sector for
decades. "Do No Environmental Harm" appears to be a
new concept that expands upon this existing
principle. What exactly does it entail?
Dorothea: The idea of incorporating an ecological
dimension into the "Do No Harm" principle to create
"Do No Environmental Harm" is actually not entirely
new. In fact, the German Federal Foreign Office’s
website, which outlines the foundations of
humanitarian aid, explicitly states that
humanitarian operations must not cause environmental
damage.
While the environmental aspect is implicitly
included in the "Do No Harm" principle, it remains
just that implicit. There is a lack of concrete
implementation strategies and, crucially, targeted
funding.
In 2024, following a training session organized by
Aktion Deutschland Hilft, I formed a working group on
sustainability with colleagues from other aid
organizations. In mid-2025, we published a position
paper on better integrating environmental
considerations into the "Do No Harm" framework,
advocating for greater attention to and a stronger
emphasis on environmental factors within humanitarian
aid.
Why is this important?
Preventing human suffering must remain our primary
objective and not just during the acute emergencies
to which we respond with our aid operations. If our
interventions end up damaging the natural resources
upon which people depend for their livelihoods, we
are merely deferring that suffering to a later time
and in doing so, we fail to fulfill our humanitarian
mandate.
At first glance, environmental protection and
emergency relief might seem like competing
priorities. After all, in times of crisis or
following a disaster, the focus is primarily on
people and the alleviation of humanitarian hardship.
But what does “do no environmental harm” look like
in practice? How can emergency relief and
environmental protection be integrated in concrete
terms?
First and foremost, it is essential to move away from
an “either/or” mindset and instead view environmental
protection and humanitarian aid as complementary tasks.
Incorporating sustainability into humanitarian projects
is no easy feat; however, there are proven tools
available to minimize the ecological footprint of an
aid operation from the very outset.
What are these tools?
One example is the “Nexus Environmental Assessment Tool,”
or NEAT+ for short. It allows us to conduct rapid
environmental assessments ideally before a project
begins. The tool analyzes potential environmental risks
associated with a given aid project and identifies ways
to minimize or entirely eliminate those risks.
For instance, consider an aid project in Burkina Faso
aimed at providing food to internally displaced persons
and their host families. This typically involves
non-perishable staples like rice, millet, or beans. These
foods must be cooked often over open fires or on basic
stoves that consume large quantities of firewood or
charcoal.
In such a case, following an environmental screening, I
would recommend also distributing fuel-efficient
cookstoves. These save significant amounts of fuel. In
addition, I would recommend reforestation efforts to
compensate for the extra consumption of raw materials.
Looking at your example from Burkina Faso, one might ask:
why wasn’t it done this way from the start? Why are aid
organizations only now beginning to systematically
consider the environmental impact of their projects?
I believe that those working in humanitarian aid and
those in the environmental sector are, in fact, quite
different groups of people who do not necessarily
communicate with one another on a regular basis which
is likely why the problem was underestimated for so
long.
A shift in thinking is taking place today because we
are increasingly confronted with crises directly
linked to environmental issues, such as the climate
crisis. This summer, for instance, we have seen
forests burning in Canada and southwestern Europe
following prolonged droughts, while coastal cities
like Accra and Abidjan have been left underwater by
torrential rains, and people in northern India have
been buried by mudslides.
Anything that fuels the climate crisis also leads to
more extreme weather events, which in turn trigger
humanitarian crises. Consequently, new types of
humanitarian interventions are now required—ones that
focus on both aspects simultaneously.
What is required to make “Do No Environmental Harm”
the standard across all humanitarian aid? Do donors
such as the Federal Foreign Office play a role in
this?
Public funding plays a major role. After all, donors
like the Federal Foreign Office often decide which
measures within aid projects are funded and which are
not. However, aid organizations themselves can also
do a great deal: for instance, they can raise
awareness among their staff regarding environmental
issues and mandate adherence to specific standards.
Practical tools such as the aforementioned
environmental screening tool, NEAT+ are also
essential. In July of this year, we addressed a
position paper to policymakers and funding
institutions, pointing out that budget cuts were
jeopardizing the funding for NEAT+.
As a result, the very existence of the tool is at
risk. We have called for a funding package to save
it. It has garnered significant attention, and
NEAT+ is once again being discussed more actively
which is exactly what we aimed to achieve.
Private donations also constitute an important part
of the funding for aid projects. For many donors,
the primary concern is that their money directly
benefits people in need. How would you explain to
donors why “green” emergency aid is important and
why donations should be used for this purpose?
I would tell them that there is hardly a more
direct way for their money to reach those in need
than through green emergency aid. Often, however,
the impact only becomes apparent later on. When
damage is prevented from occurring in the first
place, the extent of what was averted is frequently
underestimated a phenomenon known as the
“prevention paradox.” Consequently, environmental
and climate protection efforts may initially appear
to be an additional, separate investment.
In the medium to long term, however, they help
prevent damage, alleviate suffering, and save costs.
Private donations can be particularly valuable in
areas where public funding is unavailable, yet
specific interventions remain necessary. In our
project example in Burkina Faso, we could use
donations to plant trees ensuring, in the process,
that our efforts to help do not cause any harm.
Thank you for your kind donation!
By Christoph Lubczyk | Project Leader
By Christoph Lubczyk | Project Leader
Project reports on GlobalGiving are posted directly to globalgiving.org by Project Leaders as they are completed, generally every 3-4 months. To protect the integrity of these documents, GlobalGiving does not alter them; therefore you may find some language or formatting issues.
If you donate to this project or have donated to this project, you can receive an email when this project posts a report. You can also subscribe for reports without donating.
Support this important cause by creating a personalized fundraising page.
Start a Fundraiser